Construction Law Insights

M&C Hauling & Constr., Inc. v. Hale, 2018 Va. Cir. LEXIS 114 (Cir. Ct. Fairfax Cnty. June 28, 2018)

In Virginia, a party has five years to bring a claim based on a written contract, but only three years to sue for breach of a verbal or non-written contract. In this case, the sub-subcontractor’s claim was out of time unless certain unsigned documents were considered to be a written contract.

William Hale d/b/a Mulch, Topsoil and Stone (the “General Contractor”) entered into a subcontract with Hauling Unlimited (the “Subcontractor”) for truck hauling services. The Subcontractor then entered into a sub-tier subcontract with M&C Hauling and Construction, Inc. (the “Sub-Subcontractor”) for the same services. The Sub-Subcontractor provided the requested hauling services to Subcontractor and issued written daily sales tickets that listed the number of hours worked on a particular date. Sub-Subcontractor’s daily sales tickets were signed by the General Contractor, but not the Subcontractor. Although Sub-Subcontractor’s hourly rate was not listed on its daily sales tickets, it was later stated in an invoice from Sub-Subcontractor that was billed to the General Contractor.

Alone, the plain language of Virginia’s statutes of limitation for written contracts suggests that a written contract must be signed by the party being charged with its breach. However, the Supreme Court of Virginia in Dixon v. Hassell & Folkes, P.C. stated “an unsigned agreement all terms of which are embodied in a writing, unconditionally assented to by both parties, is a written contract.” 283 Va. 456, 460, 723 S.E.2d 383, 385 (2012). Therefore, Dixon’s definition of a written contract removes the signature requirement for unsigned written agreements, unless a party’s signature is an express condition in the contract.

Here, all terms of the agreement, including the rate and hours worked, were committed to writing in the Sub-Subcontractor’s daily sales tickets and invoice, without any dispute. Although there was no signature anywhere by the Subcontractor, the parties did not make their signatures a condition precedent to the formation of the contract. Using the Dixon Court’s definition of a written contract, the Fairfax Circuit Court determined that the documents were a written contract and Virginia’s five-year statute of limitations for written contracts applied. The lawsuit was not found to be late and the Sub-Subcontractor was allowed to proceed forward with its case.

PLDR Law Mark Burgin 1

Office Hours

Monday - Friday
8:30 a.m. - 5:00 p.m.
Saturday Closed
Sunday Closed

Contact Us

925 Main St., Suite 300 
Lynchburg, VA 24504 


312 Main St., Suite 200 
Danville, VA 24541 



This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
pldr law firm facebook icon